alternatehistory.com
Forums
New posts
Search forums
What's new
New posts
New profile posts
New threadmarks
Latest activity
Members
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Log in
Register
What's new
Search
Search
Search titles only
By:
Word Count:
Registered members
Current visitors
New profile posts
Search profile posts
Menu
Log in
Register
Install the app
Install
Members
JavaScript is disabled. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an
alternative browser
.
Garrison's latest activity
Garrison
replied to the thread
What if Churchill didn't under-estimate the Turks at gallipoli?
.
I'm not sure there is a successful version of this battle for the British, because if you assess the Turks capabilities accurately it...
Yesterday at 2:30 PM
Garrison
replied to the thread
The Germans build carriers, instead of battleships, prior to WW2
.
I suspect that would meet with fierce resistance from all quarters in the Luftwaffe, the RLM and from the German aircraft industry.
Yesterday at 8:42 AM
Garrison
replied to the thread
What if WWI ended in 1916 with a status quo ante bellum?
.
Didn't we have this same discussion last week? And I think @EasternRomanEmpire has summed it up pretty nicely. I would only add that the...
Yesterday at 8:05 AM
Garrison
reacted to
EasternRomanEmpire's post
in the thread
What if WWI ended in 1916 with a status quo ante bellum?
with
Like
.
There's no way they go with an status quo ante, all states when they joined wanted something and with a white peace they don't get that...
Yesterday at 8:03 AM
Garrison
reacted to
sonofpegasus's post
in the thread
An AH Battle: An Alternate Battle of the Denmark Straight - (Operation Rheinübung) 1942.
with
Like
.
T2, Whilst your alt battleships seem reasonable I do have issue with your cruisers design. Are both the Admiralty and the RCNC all...
Friday at 2:39 PM
Garrison
reacted to
allanpcameron's post
in the thread
Sir John Valentine Carden Survives. Part 2.
with
Like
.
15 June 1942. Salisbury Plain, England. The Baron II’s trials were complete and a group of Officers, Other Ranks and civilians were...
Thursday at 4:38 PM
Garrison
reacted to
TDM's post
in the thread
WW1 starts with Tanks
with
Like
.
The problem will be the "great powers" will all look at the Russo-Japanese war and say to themselves "that won't happen to us, because...
Thursday at 6:03 AM
Garrison
reacted to
Evil Crusader's post
in the thread
What if Britain became communist before WW1
with
Like
.
ASB. 1910 Britain is simply not conducive to Communism,
Thursday at 6:02 AM
Garrison
reacted to
Fries's post
in the thread
How powerful could Italy have become by 1940 if it wasn't run by a strutting buffoon?
with
Like
.
If Italy gets involved militarily it's going to struggle anyways, methinks. Italian soldiers were very well disciplined and trained, but...
Thursday at 6:02 AM
Garrison
reacted to
Lalli's post
in the thread
How powerful could Italy have become by 1940 if it wasn't run by a strutting buffoon?
with
Like
.
Depends about POD but probably only slightly stronger than in OTL.
Thursday at 6:01 AM
Garrison
replied to the thread
What if the German western campaign of 1940 does not invade or occupy Netherlands?
.
Isn't that rather a repeat of the WWI strategy, which lead to an overcrowded battlespace in Belgium and hampered German operations. Also...
Tuesday at 5:42 PM
Garrison
reacted to
Anarch King of Dipsodes's post
in the thread
What if the German western campaign of 1940 does not invade or occupy Netherlands?
with
Like
.
Oh, yes, that would be very clever. Get 500,000 or so troops from somewhere (they had vast numbers just standing around with nothing to...
Tuesday at 5:40 PM
Garrison
reacted to
CV12Hornet's post
in the thread
The Germans build carriers, instead of battleships, prior to WW2
with
Like
.
Counterpoint: Apologies for the alignment of the pic, but a relevant passage for easier reading: Tl;dr the Italians needed to...
Tuesday at 3:15 PM
Garrison
replied to the thread
AHWI: No schlieffen plan
.
Okay but what are you proposing instead? Some 1914 equivalent of Case Yellow? Or the Central Powers strike east only? What's your take?
Tuesday at 3:01 PM
Garrison
reacted to
EasternRomanEmpire's post
in the thread
WI: Kühlmann's "Peace Kite" Flies, a Negotiated End to WWI in 1917?
with
Like
.
The end of WW1 means the Ottoman Straits are free for any support to the Whites. Treaty of Montreux was in 1936 so it's irrelevant and...
May 13, 2024
Members
Top